International Students in America and the Case for More Equitable Financial Aid

I recently travelled to New England for a few days to see family and friends and to pick my little brother up from sleep-away camp. While I was there, I decided to visit a few small liberal arts colleges as well since I will be applying to colleges this year. During each information session, the admissions counselor, without fail, would make a point of discussing their school’s robust financial aid program, and for good reason; higher education has historically excluded students from disadvantaged backgrounds. But, particularly after two summer programs where I had numerous peers from all over the world, one group of applicants was flagrantly glossed over in these discussions of financial aid: international students. Perhaps their omission was an unfortunate byproduct of a program tailored to domestic applicants, an intentional decision to save time, or a mere oversight. However, I suspected there were other reasons these sessions did not readily offer up such information.
While all three schools practice need-blind admissions—where an applicant’s ability to pay tuition and other fees is not factored into the ultimate admission decision—for domestic students, just one does so for international students. Only four colleges in total—Harvard, Yale, Princeton and Amherst—have fully need-blind approaches for all students. The two schools I visited that do not have need-blind admissions for all students could offer various explanations as to why they do not: a prioritization of disadvantaged domestic students, a commitment to the more immediate communities they inhabit, or a simple inability to make financial aid available to all deserving applicants from other countries. One of the schools has a cap on how many international students can receive financial aid in proportion to the amount of international students paying in full. (However, they claim this self-imposed limit does not usually alter the makeup of the group of admitted students.) The other simply states that they are need-aware for international applicants without any further information. I do not believe it is reasonable to expect all universities to have as generous a financial aid program as those of the schools listed above, but I do think we American students should consider the difficulties low and middle income international students face in attempting to attain an education in what should be a land of opportunity.
Though contemporary conversations surrounding immigration are fraught with divisive rhetoric and absolutist perspectives, the value of supporting international students who are in pursuit of degrees from American universities should be obvious. Aside from the novel perspectives and unique background they bring to a college campus, students from other countries also are often just as qualified as—if not more qualified than—their domestic counterparts. State-run universities perform the valuable and very necessary role of offering relatively inexpensive education to its residents. But, for private universities, even those that place an unofficial limit on the number of international students they serve, applicants’ socioeconomic status should not be the determining factor in their admission or rejection. If this shift necessitates a slight reduction in the number of international students or demands a wholesale restructuring of a university’s priorities, so be it. No international student should be turned away from the wealthiest of American educational institutions because of their ability to pay.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

American Immigration and the Folly of Isolationism

Image
During the last decade, immigration has taken center stage in many political movements in the West. Frustrations with the apparent shortcomings of immigration fueled the rise of both far-right populism in Western Europe and the current American presidency. The underlying causes of this resentment or suspicion of immigration range from economic stagnation to increasing globalization to purportedly threatened cultural norms, yet the demonization of newcomers, particularly those from Latin American or Middle Eastern countries, is a common thread. However, the economic impact of immigration has long been understood by economists as generally positive, particularly in cases of movement from poorer to wealthier countries. In a novel way of going about opinion writing, Philippe Legrain outlines his support for and dispels negative misperceptions of immigration as a social phenomenon. In what is known as an Open Essay in The Economist , Legrain explains his reasoning for preferring immigratio
Read more

Global Scholars Application Essay

In the United States, the resolution of governmental legislation is too often minimized to the impact it will have on the American people in order to signal the bill or policy’s proponents’ sole investment in their constituents. Not only does this tendency preclude the realization of America’s potential as a leader on the world stage, it also ignores this country’s responsibility to our fellow global citizens as citizens of the globe ourselves. The nationalist notion of putting America first, moreover, is not limited to politics but pervades many aspects of our society, reflected in conversation, media, and personal beliefs. Through my immersion in communities with global ties, both at home and abroad, I have realized the devastatingly reductive nature of this idea and have begun to more critically appraise what my role is, not only as an American but as a human. From outreach work in Nicaragua to community engagement here in Los Angeles, from the use of Spanish in Ecuador to its fami
Read more

Reflection on Final Grant Proposal Presentation to '21 Global Scholars Cohort and Others

Image
A little over a week ago, I had the amazing opportunity to reflect on my experience completing a grant proposal through the Global Scholars program. I invited various members of the Poly community, including my fellow Global Scholars in the class of 2020, the rising Global Scholars cohort, and folks from the Poly administration who supported me in my grant proposal work. I was ecstatic to have over forty people tune in to the video call, over which I made my presentation and hosted a brief question-and-answer session. As the last formal part of the grant proposal process, the event was a time for me to reflect on what I had achieved and to share with others what I had learned. I began the presentation by explaining what led me to participate in the Global Scholars program and, specifically, the grant proposal project. I then walked the audience through the presentation that I gave to the grant proposal panelists, who were responsible for making the decision regarding who would
Read more